John 4:24
An AI-assisted draft, not yet checked by a named reviewer.
- Balanced
- God is spirit, and anyone who worships Him has to do it in spirit and truth.”
- Literal
- God [is] spirit, and it is necessary for those who worship Him to worship in spirit and truth.”
- Readable
- God is spirit. So when people worship Him, they need to worship in spirit and in truth.”
The Greek
πνεῦμα ὁ θεός, καὶ τοὺς προσκυνοῦντας αὐτὸν ἐν πνεύματι καὶ ἀληθείᾳ δεῖ προσκυνεῖν.
Word for word
Spirit the God [is], and the ones worshiping him in spirit and truth it is necessary to worship.”
Why ours reads this way
What the original says
God is spirit: what God is, not “a spirit” and not the Holy Spirit
Also considered: God is a spirit, one among many; God is the Spirit
πνεῦμα stands first without the article and describes God’s nature, like “God is light” (1 John 1:5) and “God is love” (1 John 4:8). God is not bound to a body or a place, so he cannot be confined to one mountain or one city (compare 1 Kings 8:27). Since it describes God’s being and does not name the Holy Spirit, the book-wide choice is not to capitalize it.
must: a necessity that comes from who God is
The woman spoke of the place where people “must” worship (verse 20). Jesus answers with a “must” that rests on God’s own nature, not on a place.
in spirit and truth: as in verse 23 Uncertain
Also considered: in the Spirit and in truth
See meaning decision m3 at verse 23, whose footnote gives the other reading.
those who worship him: men and women alike
The masculine plural participle is general.
How the wording was chosen
it is necessary for those who worship him to worship
Also considered: those who worship him must worship
Keeps the Greek shape, with the necessity stated before the worship it governs.
anyone who worships him (B); when people worship him (R)
Also considered: those who worship him
Plain words that include men and women without needing the gender setting.